Home > News

Apple in Trouble in Canada for Planned Obsolescence of Devices

By Laura Tucker
News Apple Planned Obsolescence Featured2

Apple has been fighting this for a few years. Once iPhone users learned that the company intentionally slowed down devices with older batteries, it has been the assumption that this was done for the purpose of forcing people to buy new phones and not hold on to their older ones. This has been disproven, but the fight rages on.

Despite Apple’s “planned obsolescence” being disproven, they have lost a lawsuit in Quebec, Canada. The litigation reached Quebec’s Supreme Court, and they decided Apple was dishonest with their claims regarding their devices with a rechargeable battery and weren’t clear regarding the AppleCare and AppleCare+ coverage.

Lawsuit Decision

The lawsuit against Apple alleged the company was dishonest with Quebec residents who bought Apple devices after December 29, 2014, and those who purchased the extra warranty coverage after December 20, 2015.

The claim worked off Apple’s admissions that it intentionally slowed down devices with older batteries to prevent then from randomly shutting down. One of the plaintiffs had an iPhone 5 that they said became “completely useless” after going through an Apple software update.

Along with the phone battery issue, however, the lawsuit complained that Apple wasn’t clear with customers regarding the AppleCare extended warranty. It’s their belief the coverage that is provided isn’t worth the price they charge for it.

News Apple Planned Obsolescence Charging

Unclear in fliers for the lawsuit was what they considered a “reasonable” amount of time would be for batteries to last. Lithium-ion batteries all become less useful as they age. This will affect battery life, which will then affect the performance of a device.

This happens with all devices, whether they are Apple or not and is why batteries are considered consumables, meaning they often aren’t protected by consumer laws.

Also not clear was Apple’s intention when it intentionally began slowing devices with older batteries down when they pushed out the iOS 10.2.1 update.

Yet, this was not planned obsolescence. Apple started slowing down the devices, performance throttling, to prevent them from randomly slowing down, something that happens with all older lithium-ion batteries.

Apple issued performance updates to fix the problem with the current iOS 12, issued a cheaper battery replacement program, and will implement new methods of saving the battery in iOS 13, which is expected to be released this coming September.

Apple Loses Lawsuit

Nevertheless, Quebec’s Supreme Court has decided residents who bought an Apple device or the AppleCare extended warranty may be eligible for up to $300 in compensation. However, this only applies to Quebec residents.

The question remains, however, if this will reach Apple users elsewhere and continue the disinformation being spread that Apple implements planned obsolescence, even though the companies feels throttling performance is better than the batteries becoming unusable as they age.

Do you have an Apple device that slowed down when the battery got older? Do you still believe it’s planned obsolescence? Howe does this court decision affect you? Chime in to the comments below.

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Our latest tutorials delivered straight to your inbox

Laura Tucker Avatar
Laura Tucker
Laura has spent more than 20 years writing news, reviews, and op-eds, with the majority of those years as an editor as well. She has exclusively used Apple products for the past 35 years. In addition to writing and editing at MTE, she also runs the site’s sponsored review program.

Read next

From below of blue starry sky over radio telescope and trees with leaves
The Big Ear telescope was scanning at 1420.4056 megahertz on the night of 15 August 1977, the exact frequency at which hydrogen atoms vibrate across the universe, because Giuseppe Cocconi and Philip Morrison had argued years earlier that any species trying to be found would broadcast on that channel — and then, for 72 seconds, something did.
In 2016, archaeologists dated two rings of snapped stalagmites in France’s Bruniquel Cave to 176,500 years ago, evidence that Neanderthals had walked 336 metres into darkness with fire and built architecture deep underground long before modern humans reached Europe
Otto von Bismarck was 74 when Germany adopted the world’s first national old-age social insurance program in 1889, setting the pension age at 70 after years of fighting socialists with bans, laws, and a promise few workers would live long enough to use
When cosmonaut Valeri Polyakov stepped out of his Soyuz capsule in March 1995 after 437 consecutive days aboard Mir, doctors recorded him at several centimetres above his pre-flight height, and his spine had become so unaccustomed to gravity that the recovery team carried him to a chair rather than risk the compression of letting him walk.
When Bell Labs engineer Karl Jansky pointed a rotating antenna at the sky in 1932 looking for sources of transatlantic radio static, he kept picking up a faint hiss that peaked every 23 hours and 56 minutes, and he eventually realized he had become the first human to hear the center of the Milky Way.
A contemplative scene with two scientists in a vintage laboratory setting.
When Harvard astronomer Cecilia Payne submitted her 1925 doctoral thesis arguing that the Sun was made almost entirely of hydrogen, the field’s senior figure Henry Norris Russell talked her into adding a line calling the result ‘almost certainly not real,’ and then published the same conclusion himself four years later to widespread acclaim.
When seismic waves from the Chicxulub impact reached what is now North Dakota roughly ten minutes after the asteroid struck, they appear to have triggered a ten-metre standing wave in an inland river that flung fish onto the bank and buried them under glass beads still falling from the sky.
When survivors near Lake Nyos woke on the morning of 22 August 1986, the cattle were dead in the fields, the birds had fallen out of the trees, and 1,746 of their neighbours were lying where they had stood the night before, with no fire, no flood, and no wound to explain it.