Home > Tech Explained

What Is “Right to Repair” Legislation? [MTE Explains]

By Miguel Leiva-Gomez
right-to-repair-featured

A new trend is arriving, chiefly in the United States, where device manufacturers will have to comply with certain regulations in order to make it easier for their customers to get repairs for the things they own. This package of legislation, which was enacted in California on March 8, 2018, has several implications for customers but also for the market as a whole, all of which warrants a significant amount of discussion regarding all these effects.

What Is Right to Repair?

righttorepair-teardown

Technically, if a state in the U.S. enacts “Right to Repair” legislation, it establishes a framework by which device manufacturers will be obligated to provide an easy way to acquire the official hardware they use to manufacture their devices.

Right now, for example, you usually have two choices. You can take your device to a service center approved by the manufacturer, wait several days for the problem to be fixed, and pony up a large sum of money if the device is not under warranty. Your other choice is to take it to an unofficial service center that doesn’t necessarily have access to official replacement parts but can “wing it” in such a way that your device works by the end of the day, and you end up paying significantly less for the repair.

California’s Right to Repair legislation provides one more obligation for device manufacturers like Apple: they must provide guidance for customers to be able to repair their own devices if they want to.

This takes things a bit further and allows people to make their own home repairs without having to take the device in for service at all, opening up the possibility for them to buy official replacement parts and save on the labor costs involved by not taking their stuff to service centers. It’s effectively a third option that cuts out all the middlemen and offers a significant degree of freedom to users who own their devices.

Mom and Pop Freedom

righttorepair-service

“Right to Repair” legislation eliminates the exclusivity that some manufacturers have enforced over the years, making their customers effectively reliant on them to repair the devices that they (presumably) own.

This would allow smaller repair centers to have the access they need to help their customers more efficiently, lowering the prices of repairs for warranty-less devices overall.

We can expect to see more small “Mom & Pop” service centers pop up, offering repairs that compete with original manufacturers with a lower price point.

In addition to all of this, we get the largest thing to complete the trifecta: more adventurous people can just tinker with their devices at home, finding new ways to solve problems.

All of this translates into a dynamic that might actually be innovative at some point. As more average Joes learn how their devices work, they might find new ways to solve problems that have been plaguing manufacturers for years. This is the kind of thing that happened in the golden era of the desktop PC, when OEMs began implementing innovations worked out by hobbyists in their own homes.

Do you think there are any caveats or possible negative effects to Right to Repair legislation? Let us know what you think in a comment!

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Our latest tutorials delivered straight to your inbox

Miguel Leiva-Gomez Avatar
Miguel Leiva-Gomez
Miguel has been a business growth and technology expert for more than a decade and has written software for even longer. From his little castle in Romania, he presents cold and analytical perspectives to things that affect the tech world.

Read next

Russia still custom-builds the Soyuz return seats for ISS crew members using plaster casts taken weeks before launch, because astronauts grow as much as five centimetres taller during a long-duration stay and a seat moulded to their Earth-shaped spine would no longer fit the body that comes home
Close-up of a young adult using a smartphone outdoors, highlighting modern technology and connectivity.
The “CrackBerry” nickname stuck for a reason — and the variable-reward psychology that hooked early-2000s executives on their BlackBerrys is the exact same machinery now running every push notification on every smartphone in your pocket
In 1843, Ada Lovelace described a brass-and-punched-card engine that could act on symbols as well as numbers, even composing music if harmony could be reduced to rules, inside seven translator’s notes three times longer than the paper itself
Bright modern laboratory with computers and technical equipment for research and analysis.
ARPANET sent its first message on 29 October 1969 from a lab at UCLA to a machine at Stanford, and the message was supposed to read ‘LOGIN’ — but the system crashed after the L and the O, meaning the first word ever transmitted over the network that became the internet was, by accident, ‘LO’.
In 1995, Microsoft shipped a cartoon-house interface called Bob, led by Melinda French, who married Bill Gates while it was in development — it demanded twice the memory of a typical home PC, sold roughly 30,000 copies, and was dead within a year, leaving behind the font Comic Sans and the animated assistant that became Clippy.
Stunning underwater shot of tiger sharks swimming among fish in the ocean depths.
The Greenland shark grows about one centimetre a year, does not reach sexual maturity until around age 150, and a specimen carbon-dated by Danish researchers in 2016 was estimated to be at least 272 years old, meaning it was already swimming the North Atlantic when Mozart was composing symphonies.
A person using a smartphone with a green screen surrounded by fresh fruits and vegetables in the kitchen.
When Apple shipped iOS 12 in June 2018, a small feature called Screen Time slipped onto every iPhone with a counter nobody had quite prepared for — a tally of pickups — and within a day Tim Cook was telling CNN the number of times he picked up his own phone was simply too many
Starry night with radio towers and the Milky Way galaxy visible overhead.
When NASA lost contact with the IMAGE satellite in 2005, an amateur radio operator in Canada named Scott Tilley picked up its signal in January 2018 while hunting for a classified spy satellite, and the spacecraft turned out to be still spinning, still powered, and still trying to phone home after 13 years of silence.